|
NEW YORK, NY (July 15, 2004) — It is the American Society for Aesthetic
Plastic Surgery's (ASAPS) position that, currently, lipoplasty (liposuction) is
the only proven method for the permanent reduction of fat deposits. Recently,
however, news of a non-invasive alternative to surgical fat reduction has begun
to receive attention. The product, LipoSonix's SonoSculpt, is based on
high-intensity ultrasound technology.
ASAPS President, Peter Fodor , MD, says the product is promising enough that
he plans to discuss it at the upcoming 17 th Biennial Congress of the
International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery (ISAPS) which meets in August
in Houston.
“The concept behind the LipoSonix device is to allow the surgeon to
non-invasively disrupt and selectively reduce fatty tissue,” says Dr. Fodor.
“Ultimately, I believe this technology could revolutionize the approach to
body sculpting."
Leroy Young , MD, Chair of ASAPS Nonsurgical Procedures Committee notes that
the LipoSonix device represents an extension of the medical uses of ultrasonic
energy. “We know that it is possible to disrupt fatty tissues,” he says. “What
we need is clinical trials approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to
define its applications. For example,” he continues, “we need to know who
would be appropriate candidates for this procedure, and what areas can be
treated. We also need to know if there are areas that need to be excluded.
Finally,” he says, “we need to find out the potential long-term consequences
of its use and any potential complications.”
Dr. Fodor agrees. “The LipoSonix device is intriguing and appears to be
safe, but questions remain. For example,” he says, “surgeons would need to
be able to control the depth of the effects. There needs to be further research
to determine if the procedure could affect cells other than fat cells.
Controlled scientific studies are necessary to ensure safety and validate the
results.”
Similar questions have been raised about Ultrashape, another device that
employs ultrasound to treat localized fat deposits noninvasively. Claims as to
the safety and efficacy of this product have so far not been substantiated by
scientific clinical trials in the United States .
Get quotes from local service providers
|
|
|
|
Additionally, there have been articles in popular consumer magazines
describing the injection of phosphatidylcholine, a phospholipid that is known by
the trade name of Lipostabil. Claims state that this substance dissolves fat
without the need for surgical intervention. ASAPS cautions that the safety and
effectiveness of this procedure are unproven.
Licensed physicians may legally offer treatments involving off-label uses of
many pharmacologic substances, as long as such substances have been approved by
the Food and Drug Administration for other uses and there is no specific
prohibition of the intended off-label use. Currently, however, Lipostabil is not
approved for any use in this country . In addition, there does not appear to be
sufficient scientific and clinical data to substantiate the safety and
effectiveness of phosphatidylcholine (Lipostabil) as a fat-dissolving treatment.
Specific questions should be answered before any of these products can be
safety used:
How can it be assured that the appropriate amount of fat – neither too
little nor too much -- is dissolved?
If fatty tissue is being dissolved, is other tissue also affected? How is
delivery limited to only the target tissues?
What are the short-term and long-term side-effects? Is there the possibility
that side-effects could include cell death?
A great deal of the currently published research in aesthetic plastic surgery
focuses on the development of minimally invasive procedures that can improve a
patient's appearance with fewer risks and shorter recovery than traditional
surgery. The way in which safety and effectiveness of new procedures is
determined, in preparation for their widespread use in properly selected
patients, is through careful scientific and clinical research. Such research is
evaluated through publication of results in reputable, peer-reviewed medical
journals and presentation of results at medical meetings such as those sponsored
by ASAPS and other accredited Continuing Medical Education sponsors.
|